Rights to Light, a challenge for developers & funders

Rights to Light, a challenge for Developers and Funders

One of the aspects of property due diligence that I love is the continual opportunity to grow my knowledge on aspects of law and construction. Every development is unique and brings its own peculiarities but, a bit like buses, I do then see phases where a previously infrequent issue crops up on multiple cases at once. One such example is on ROL (Rights to Light) and following requests from a number of colleagues, I have agreed to focus the spotlight here for this blog.

Normally, we would start at the beginning but as that started with ‘the word’, let’s just skip forward the light bit…

What is ROL?

A right to light is an easement; in other words, it is an acquired benefit to the enjoyment of the light that passes over another’s land and enters via an aperture into a building. It is not an automatic entitlement and rarely documented in the deed (personally, I have only seen this twice – where someone has sold off a portion of their land and clarified ROL on titles at Land Registry).

How is ROL acquired?

Unless clearly stated in the deed, any ROL would need to be proven. However, ROL may be acquired by anyone who has had uninterrupted access and use of light to and for any dwelling house, workshop, or other building for a period of 20 years, openly and without threat, with no interruption for more than a year. The complication arises that if the aperture has moved at some time, if there have been historic agreements to receive light across the neighbouring land, if there has been an unchallenged interruption of more than a year to the light etc it is difficult to know whether there is still a case for ROL or as a Developer, whether or not you would infringe upon ROL.

I have planning permission – so this doesn’t affect me

A common misunderstanding that I see is the assumption that because someone has planning permission, a neighbour cannot make a claim to ROL. Unfortunately, this is not the case! Whilst planners consider questions of daylight and sunlight when assessing a planning proposal, ROL is a point of law and not planning. Therefore, pressing on with a development, even with approved planning, can leave you open to a dispute, claim and potential injunction from the court. Furthermore, it is worth noting that even where buildings have been completed, the court can require alterations to the building to remedy the offending parts and award damages to the offended parties. This is potentially a lengthy and costly process.

Can I insure against the risk?

Indemnity insurance is often our friend when it comes to issues of defective titles and easements. However, due to the complexity of ROL it is not recommended that insurance be viewed as a cure-all to the issue. One reason for this is that traditional indemnity policies often require that there be no disclosure of the problem, otherwise it invalidates the policy. However, in ROL cases, the courts will take into consideration the efforts to liaise with potentially affected neighbours and an injunction might be more likely in instances where there has been no contact at all. Appropriate insurance policies do exist, but they are not an ‘off the shelf’ product and can be very costly. For example, I know of one development where the cost of ROL insurance was circa 1% of the GDV. In that instance, expert third party opinions of the policy were also required from an independent insurance expert and quantity surveyor before all parties got comfortable.

What does this mean for a Developer?

ROL should be considered by any Developer that will build in the vicinity of existing buildings. Given the current trend to go up and the regeneration of brownfield sites, this is the case for most sites I see. Due to the complexity of the issue, a survey by an ROL specialist is always recommended and organisations such as https://www.rics.org/ can help you find someone appropriately qualified in your area. It is always better to address the issue at the start and factor it into the costs of your development and the programme for construction: funders will always welcome pro-active Developers that present proposals addressing such issues. The courts are also likely to look more favourably on Developers that have taken the appropriate steps to avoid going to court in the first instance.

Blog written by our very own Credit Operations Manager, Alexandra Phillips BA (Hons), PgDip, ACMI
November 2019


"A challenging site like no other with every inch of the plot being built on and 12 apartments built-out through a driveway 2.5m wide off of a main high street with limited access rights, not to mention all the complexities associated with 13 Party Wall Agreements. Most lenders would not have had the vision for the scheme or the confidence in Spiller Builders to build out the scheme.  I just wanted to say how helpful the entire BLG team have been during the build. A very approachable and knowledgeable team, with a “can do” approach to lending. We will be looking to do more business with you for sure."

“We have used BLG for development finance for over 8 years. During that time we have found their knowledge and expertise in the property development industry to be second to none. Their loan process, pragmatic and flexible approach to lending and flexibility when required has supported our business needs throughout the period and provided us with support to deliver new homes in Bristol and the surrounding areas.”

“As property developers you never know the curve balls that you may get and a project that is great on paper may prove a bit more tricky.  This happened to us on a project that BLG have funded and throughout they have supported us.  Our business likes to be collaborative and when we hit those tough moments it really felt like we were working as a team with BLG.  If you have a decent project you can get it funded, but what you really need is a business that is there to support and advise you as well.  For us on this project it was BLG.”

“I approached BLG Development finance with an opportunity I had in Chesham, Buckinghamshire, to build 5 new build houses in 2021. My main contact was Anil Bains who is a Director covering Asset Management. Within very quick timescales, BLG provided me with indicative quotes in regards the finance levels they could offer me. Having considered those levels, I requested a valuation to be carried out which again was dealt with swiftly. We proceeded to completion. The build went very smoothly with monthly monitoring being carried out by BLG and monthly drawdown requests dealt with in a very timely manner. Due to a difficult time generally in the market in regards selling, I was in need of a six-month extension to the loan which again was appraised very quickly and granted. Having dealt with numerous funders over the last 20 years, I can only speak highly of my personal experience with BLG and would very confidently work with them again on any future projects. “

"From our side it has also been a pleasure working with BLG and the team there. We have found you easy to deal with, proactive in resolving any minor issues that have arisen through the project and shown great flexibility in working with us as a partner. We will certainly like to work with you on future partners."

“I really appreciate your hard work. We really like the way you communicate & I must say I haven't seen many people who are that approachable.”

“A very efficient processing team, dealing with the DD once deal credit approved, through to completion”

“Many thanks for your efforts on this one and getting it approved and sorted so swiftly, very much appreciated. I am sure I will be speaking to your over the coming months.”

“We had other funding options, but chose to use BLG again, as we work well with the team, who always provide very clear information and advice with a friendly approach throughout the funding process. Very efficient and always very helpful.”

“Many thanks Anil, it’s been a real pleasure working with BLG so far.  We’re lining up the next project too”

“We would recommend all staff we have dealt with at BLG, as we are very satisfied with the team and the initial offer/terms presented, then you and the funding team, through to the draw down team at valuation stage.”

“All documents are clear and the way you keep clients informed, all the way along the funding process, is refreshing for us”

“With regard to what should be improved at BLG, we work with many lenders in our business and we do not get the help and response we have had on the two projects with all at BLG on our funding for our developments.”

“We would particularly mention Dave Edwards and Tom Pitts as being central to having a smooth working relationship and being positive and helpful at all times. Their guidance in helping us navigate the project from inception to completion was invaluable. As was their patience, particularly at the beginning. We look forward to many future projects with the BLG team.”

“We would like to express our appreciation for your support on our development in Bristol. We were very pleased that, from the outset, you shared our vision of the project to convert a dated but classical building, that had outlived its usefulness as a school, into unique luxury apartments with views overlooking the city. We found our dealings practical and streamlined. Monthly payments were processed in an efficient and timely manner.”

“BLG are very good at communicating with clients and all documents are very clear and all at BLG are always happy to help.”

    Quick Enquiry?

    We’re here to help.